Deli & Grocery in Wheeling, WV – Located in Centre Market

Serving the Community for Three Generations

For three generations, the Wheeling, WV community has relied on Valley Cheese Co. for locally sourced, organic, and gourmet food items. We continue to provide our customers with the same high quality products and friendly customer service that made us a staple in Wheeling when we opened our doors back in 1948. Check out our selection of foods that are unique to the area, like Amish-made products and a variety of other specialty items. We have a relationship with the businesses whose products we sell, so you always get a knowledgeable answer to any questions you may have.

Discover why our customers have been returning to our shop for three generations. Visit Valley Cheese Co. in our original Centre Market location, in the South building, or give us a call today: (304) 232-0882.

Try the Delicious, Affordable Meals Available in Our Deli

If you live or work in Wheeling near Centre Market, stop by Valley Cheese Co. for your next meal! We offer a variety of sandwiches, soups, salads, and sides at our deli counter. We like to keep our prices low, so you can always afford to stop by on your lunch break and try something different. Our case is filled with approximately 85 varieties of meats and cheeses that make perfect sandwiches, so you can always find something you love, or something you have never tried before. We also offer daily specials and a soup of the day, so no matter when you stop by, you will always find something different.

Purchase Amish Cheeses by
the Pound, Slice, or
Sampler Tray

Valley Cheese Co. lives up to its name by offering a wide variety of cheeses in our deli. Each of our roughly 65 varieties of Amish cheese is available for purchase and is sliced to order. Purchase your favorite by the pound, try it on a sandwich with one of our delicious deli meats, or try a sampler platter of a few different cheeses and meats. We also offer a variety of Amish-style deli meats, as well as Amish-made jams, so no matter what you want to put on your sandwich, we have you covered. Check out our list of cheeses meats, and jams, then stop by today to grab your favorites!

Catering & Party Trays for Your Next Party or Event

Are you hosting a party or event and need light catering? Are you attending a potluck or similar event and need something to bring? Trust the staff at Valley Cheese Co. to help! We offer a variety of trays, pasta and macaroni salad, finger sandwiches, and more. Take a tray of our delicious Amish meats and cheeses to your party. Or grab some of our delicious pasta salad, macaroni salad, or deviled eggs to take to your family picnic. Download our party tray order form, fill it out, and bring it to our deli counter to place your order today. We recommend that you place your catering or party tray order at least 24 hours in advance so that we have time to prepare your full order. Holidays require advanced notice.

Our party trays are always affordable! View our prices!

Gift Baskets from Valley
Cheese Co.

When you need a gift for a coworker, loved one, or neighbor, look no further than Valley Cheese Co.! We can build you a gift basket your recipient is sure to love. Simply tell our staff your budget, and we will ask you some questions about what sorts of items you would like to include. Then, we create a gift basket based on your budget and needs. You can also bring items we do not sell for inclusion in the gift basket, like wine, and we will create a gift that pairs perfectly with the item. Choose to add fruit, non-perishables, and more for the perfect gift for any occasion!

Gourmet & Specialty Foods for Your Unique Recipes

Valley Cheese Co. is your destination for gourmet and specialty items. Stop by when you need something that a large, chain grocery store does not stock. We sell a wide variety of unique Amish products, including chocolates, boxed mixes, marinades, jams, noodles, and seasonal products. We also special order dry cottage cheese for our customers who make pierogies, blintzes, lasagna, and a variety of other recipes. Check out our inventory the next time you are looking for a unique item not stocked by your grocery store.

Check back for future updates

HAVE questions!? contact us today!

Close Menu